Some of you may have read one of my prior diaries, "You Boomers Asked for This, You Know." I touched on some generational themes that were relevant to the race as it was at the time. When I saw the response I got, I thought I might discuss the issue at greater length down the line.
Well, here we are.
I'd like to start by saying that a lot of the following will involve armchair anthropology. My conclusions may be wrong, given that they are based on anecdotal evidence and supposition. Some of this may not apply to you, Mr. or Mrs. particular reader. That's okay. If I make a broad assertion about a group that you belong to, it's okay if I don't describe you perfectly. This is going to be imprecise. I know that going into writing it. I ask that you do the same when reading it.
Under-30's treat the internet and messageboards generally differently than do Boomers (and so forth). We are given to using a very different set of manners whilst posting on messageboards and chatting on instant messenging (and text messaging for that matter) than we do in real world, face-to-face interaction. A lot of what we post here would be rude under other circumstances.
I think this is part of the problem. I am as young as someone can be and still remember growing up without the prevalence of the internet. Folks five or ten years my junior (I'm 28) won't recall a world where phone calls and face to face interactions were the primary way to talk with people.
The etiquette is different. Speaking for myself, I just know how to behave in the different contexts. I still pride myself in my manners, even online, but even given my desire to be considerate, the rules are still different.
The upshot of all this is very relevant to the recent rancor and anger. The younger posters, generally (though by no means exclusively) supporting Obama, managed to righteously piss off a lot of their elders. This is unfortunate. I wasn't happy to see it happen, and I regret that it ever did.
However, this is how discourse is generally done online. It's more confrontational, more terse, and "gotcha!" moments are far more prevalent. This does not speak well of internet discourse. It does seem to me to be an inferior form of discourse in many respects.
I wonder, I really do wonder, if some of you Boomers (and so forth) who tell us you've been a voting Democrat for thirty or forty years really understand this. Maybe some of you haven't really engaged online until the last few years?
This place can get rough. LOLCats, youtube clips, and more memes than I can name will be used in lieu of substantive posts because the poster assumes that the reader will understand what is meant. It is symbolism.
This diary is not meant to cover the entirety of issues between the Clinton and Obama camps. I am not diminishing, nor am I even discussing(!), the many legitimate differences and grievances the two sides may have.
I am only dealing with the friction between these two groups and the correlation between age groups and candidate-identification. I can really sum this up very quickly:
We treated you like we treat each other and I think it pissed you off.
When I see that someone is thirty years my elder, face to face, I will behave differently than I would if someone was roughly my age. I don't have that ability, generally, when posting and reading online.
This diary is meant to start a conversation, not end any sort of debate. I hope that you folks will get in on this.
FYI, this is about how people related at websites like MyDD and Kos, not the electorate more broadly
|
|
|
Permalink :: 48 Comments :: Post a Comment
|
In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.
If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.